Friday, November 20, 2026

Can the Congress make dynasty cool again?

 

  • 20 Nov, 2026



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Welcome to The India Fix by Shoaib Daniyal, a newsletter on Indian politics. As always, if you’ve been sent this newsletter and like it, to get it in your inbox every week, sign up here (click on “follow”).

Have feedback, interesting links or think I am wrong? Write to me: theindiafix@scroll.in


Of the many excerpts, thinkpieces and critiques flooding social media in the wake of the launch of former Congress president Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, one is a meme showing a made-up book called Longing written by Jashodaben Modi, the estranged wife of Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

The joke puns on the name of Gandhi’s book Belonging to take a jab at Narendra Modi, who had married Jashodaben at the age of 17. The union, by all accounts, was short-lived – but is still legally valid. However, Modi never acknowledged he had a wife till he was forced to do so in his 2014 nomination form for the Lok Sabha polls – an election that eventually saw him become prime minister. (He would leave the “wife” column blank during the four Assembly elections he fought in Gujarat.)

 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The meme circulating on Reddit.

Highlighting his teenage marriage and estranged wife is a somewhat unkind joke. Modi’s brother’s clarification that the marriage was a result of their family being “poor and uneducated” as well as “superstitious” at the time carries some weight.

Volte-face

Yet, watchers of Indian politics will be surprised at how “family” has quite suddenly turned from being one of Modi’s strengths to a weakness in the week Sonia Gandhi’s memoirs went viral. A little more than a decade ago, when Modi stormed Delhi, not having a household was one of his strongest pitches to India’s voters. Modi had “given up family for the country’s service”, Sombhai, his brother, emphasised in the same statement he had issued to argue that the Narendra-Jashodaben union was not really a marriage.

Modi, in turn, linked his lack of family to probity. “Mere liye na koi aage, na peechhey, kiske liye bhrashtaachaar karunga?” he said during the 2014 campaign. I have no one, who will I be corrupt for?

This was such a strong campaign point that the Financial Times declared during the 2014 general election that “[o]ne of Narendra Modi’s advantages as Indian prime ministerial candidate for the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party has always been his lack of a family”.

However, the hunger for Sonia Gandhi’s memoir has shown that having a family might not be all that bad when it comes to Indian politics. The book is a rare runaway bestseller in India’s otherwise bleak publishing landscape, having sold more than two lakh copies in less than a week.

Family as politics

One of the first reactions as the book went on sale on November 10 was the absence of political revelations. And indeed, for anyone looking for a political history of India as seen through Sonia’s eyes, there is little in the book. Instead, the book is about family. There is intense and often tender minutiae about her relations with her mother-in-law, Indira Gandhi, her children and, most of all, her husband Rajiv Gandhi.

But that hardly means there is no politics in the book. The lack of politics is Gandhi’s political pitch. She is selling the Gandhis to the voter. Sonia’s picture of a loving Gandhi family is meant to endear them to Indians.

Even Sanjay Gandhi, Indira’s youngest son and a person that historian Ramchandra Guha called a “vicious, vindictive politician who brought thugs and charlatans into the party of the freedom movement”, comes off looking rather well when seen through the lens of family. “Sanjay was good company, full of humour and pranks, a bit of a tease and fun,” Sonia Gandhi writes about her first impression of her then boyfriend’s younger brother in England.

At the book launch, Rahul Gandhi, the leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, doubled down on this, describing in detail the affection between his parents. On Thursday, Indira’s birth anniversary, he tweeted out a Sonia interview describing Indira in the book, with the words “Happy Birthday, Dadi”, using the familial Hindi word for paternal grandmother that he would have addressed the then prime minister as.

 

 

What the data says

How did the dynasty go from being an albatross around the Gandhis’ neck to suddenly taking wings for the Congress?

Part of the answer might lie in the fact it never really was a disadvantage at all. In 2017, when a survey asked Modi supporters what they liked about him, a grand total of 0.06% respondents answered, “Does not belong to any dynasty.” (Three times as many respondents said they liked that Modi had a “dictatorial/authoritarian nature”.)

There is little doubt that the Congress was unpopular at the time – but that might trace to more nuts and bolts reasons like inflation rather than dynasty. Almost all the data we have shows that Indians have no great antipathy towards political families. Dynastic leaders do well in elections. The 2014 Lok Sabha, for example, had more than a fifth of its members from political families.

In fact, dynasty might even help at the hustings. One survey shows that nearly half of Indian voters would prefer to vote for a candidate who belongs to a family of politicians. “When voters were asked why they supported dynastic candidates, 45% responded that they are better at politics because it is their family occupation, while another 40% believe that family-backed politicians are likely to succeed because of greater exposure to politics,” write the surveyors Milan Vaishnav, Devesh Kapur and Neelanjan Sircar.

Political scientist Kanchan Chandra argues that dynastic politics helps parties “ensure loyalty” in an environment where defections and rebellions are common. Dynasty also, “paradoxically”, she writes, helps underrepresented groups such as women, Muslims, backward castes and youth “find representation in politics”.

None of this means that dynasty is by itself a winning formula. Modi’s immense popularity is proof of that. But it is hardly the electoral poisoned chalice that the BJP’s attacks on the Gandhis suggest.

Given that, the Congress would be more than happy to see the positive buzz Sonia Gandhi’s bestseller has generated.


We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.

Source: https://indiafix.stck.me/post/2292744/Can-the-Congress-make-dynasty-cool-again